Scott Bundgaard Guest Opinion

I have never hit, pushed or abused any woman. Ever. I have never invoked legislative immunity to escape justice. On the night of February 25, 2011, I was the “victim” according to Phoenix Police officers and their reports, given a “victim rights pamphlet” and later assigned a “victim rights advocate” by the City of Phoenix Prosecutor’s Office Victim Services Unit.

Since there was no charge made that night against me, why would I assert immunity? So what changed over the following three weeks? The extensive Notice of Claim that was recently filed demonstrates that the City of Phoenix engaged in collusion and cover up in order to intentionally and maliciously destroy me.

One might ask why I waited until now to respond. I accepted a “no contest” plea agreement from the City of Phoenix Prosecutor’s Office in August, 2011, because I could not afford the “expensive court battle” that was promised by the Phoenix prosecutor.

For six months, I operated under an agreement that could have been revoked at any time and for any reason. I could not respond to the lies being perpetrated by certain Phoenix Police officers at the Senate Ethics Committee hearing without jeopardizing this agreement. I resigned from the Senate, because it was useless to respond.

It has only been over the last five months that I have realized the extent of collusion, cover up and corruption by the City of Phoenix in order to wipe me out. Those facts are presented in the Notice of Claim and is available to the public. The shocking and unacceptable practices by the City of Phoenix must end. As to State Senator Ron Gould and his Kangaroo Court, he expressed bias against me publicly for months prior to his hearing last January. He intentionally suppressed exculpatory evidence and colluded with the lead PPD investigator in this matter to further perpetrate this fraud. When people such as former Mayor Phil Gordon and State Senator Ron Gould can use their elected office for intentionally malicious purposes, it is unethical and must be exposed.

I would not wish upon anyone what I endured the past year: false accusations, intentional public defamation, political vengeance, collusion and corruption by city officials, sham proceedings, and personal and professional degradation that resulted in losing all of my income. If you want to know ‘why’ I would sue the City of Phoenix for $10 million, ask yourself how much you would have to be paid to endure personal, professional and financial destruction.

Politicians from all political parties must confront the serious issues facing our country instead of playing political games with our tax dollars. The citizens who elected me were deprived of their choice of senator by a political abuse of process. We all pay a price when the police are used as a weapon against political rivals. Taxpayers must demand public sector reforms in order to prevent further legal actions such as mine.


Scott Bundgaard

Read the Claim here.

Recent Media Coverage of Bundgaard vs. Ballard

This is still very much a “he said, she said” story about what happened late one Friday night on Highway 51.

If Senator Bundgaard is telling the truth, Ballard will likely be prosecuted heavily for any number of crimes. But if Senator Bundgaard is lying, this will be the end of his political and professional career.

This is likely going to the courts but before it does, expect local media to run back and forth between Bundgaard’s attorney and Ballard’s spokesman.

BREAKING! Bundgaard notifies GOP Caucus, Ballard pulled gun

The Arizona Guardian is reporting that State Senator Scott Bundgaard notified fellow Senate Republicans that a gun was involved in the recent highway altercation.

During a closed door session in which the GOP caucus was to consider the fate of the Majority Leader, Bundgaard revealed new information that his ex-girlfriend had pulled a gun on him while he drove home after the Dancing with the Stars event. Apparently, Ballard was intoxicated and angry and pulled the gun belonging to Bundgaard from inside the vehicle as they argued.

Nowhere in the police report does it mention that Ballard was intoxicated nor does it mention anything about a gun.

Sonoran Alliance has learned that Bundgaard apparently notified police about the gun during the incident. Phoenix police took down details about the make and model of the gun before returning it to him. Still there is no mention of the gun in their report.

Police also failed to mention that Bundgaard called a family member to assist at the incident and that a breathalizer test was performed.

This story continues to intensify especially as public criticism mounts against Bundgaard and new revelations about a failure to report critical details by Bundgaard, Ballard and the Phoenix Police Department enter the public arena.

Will Bundgaard’s shocking revelation be a game changer to the story or will the public see it as a desperate act? And will the Phoenix Police Department deny the latest claim or admit to another investigatory bungling? The courts will likely have the last word.

Phoenix PD releases police report on Bundgaard Ballard Incident

Here is the official police report for the alleged domestic violence incident that occurred between State Senator Scott Bundgaard and Aubry Ballard. (The Phoenix New Times was able to secure a copy of the report.)

Read the report and decide for yourself who is truly to blame. Both reports tell a he-said, she said account with both Bundgaard and Ballard claiming they were hit by each other. Both reports also tell two different stories of what the fight was about and what each person was threatening to do.

Looks like this will go to court for a jury to decide.

Media Coverage on Bundgaard – Ballard Incident

Here is the latest media coverage of the Scott Bundgaard – Aubry Ballard “domestic violence” incident:

KFYI – Barry Young Show

When I first heard the breaking story, I contacted someone who I trust who could provide information about what had happened. Having known Scott Bundgaard for about 10 years, hearing about the incident was a complete shock. This was not the Scott Bundgaard I have known. It was later disclosed to me that Scott’s girlfriend had admitted to being “the jealous type” to others. I don’t know this to be the case but if the reports are correct that she was smashing her cell phone into Scott’s face and throwing his clothing out of the car as it drove down the 51, I would tend to believe those accounts. One question I have that has not been answered is whether or not Ms. Ballard had consumed any alcohol Friday evening. If Scott has been aware of this and she had jumped into the driver’s seat of his car, it would seem to be a reasonable thing for him to stop her from driving off while under the influence. If she had not consumed any alcohol, this question is completely irrelevant.

As far as the issue of declaring immunity, the only people who would know the answer to that are the police, Scott and Aubry. Given media accounts, it sure seems that Scott did not boldly proclaim “Diplomatic Immunity!” as some people have claimed. I don’t know the answer to this but we may find out.

Senator’s Ex Tells Her Side of the Story:

Back to Ms. Ballard. Anyone who does the research online will note that she has been involved with a local organization called Project Streetlight/Branded Phx. According to the organization’s website, it is local leader in the eradication of child sex slavery/prostitution. Ballard is listed as a public relations representative to the organization according to a November, 2010 press release.

Senator’s Ex Tells Her Side of the Story:

Another interesting note about this story is that Ms. Ballard participated in a competition called Miss Arizona Dream Girl sometime ago. On an ESPN website written by Gregg Easterbrook, a photo of what appears to be Ballard posing as Miss Arizona Dream Girl contains the following description, “Brad Twarowski of Spring Grove, Ill., notes that the Miss Arizona Dream Girl competition spreads the wealth by choosing someone every month; gawk at Miss Arizona Dream Girl of January, Aubry Ballard, here.” As of today, that photo of Miss Ballard wearing a bikini and sporting a power drill has been removed; However, a cached file of the page was captured on December 25, 2010 and is still available. (Apparently, ESPN updated the page yesterday.) Ballard currently works for a company that specializes in internet marketing and search engine optimization.

Senator’s Ex Tells Her Side of the Story:

What does this all mean? Perhaps the best explanation of what really happened should take place in the legal courts because the court of public opinion is doing a pretty lousy job. Both Scott and Aubry deserve their day in court and the opportunity to set the record straight but in the meantime, it’s been nothing but a “have you stopped beating your wife, he-said, she said” media fiasco.

Joint Statement by State Senator Scott Bundgaard and Aubry Ballard Regarding Friday Night

CONTACT: Jason Rose


“We want to jointly apologize for allowing a private matter to interrupt the public – and especially for taking up the valuable time of law enforcement. The police officers who responded deserve thanks for their sensitivity and compassion.

We have cared for each other in the past; we wish the best for each other in the future. Like most relationships, ours has had some ups and downs, but it has always been based on our Christian faith and our respect for one another. With that in mind, we intend to go our separate ways now and put what happened Friday night and Saturday in the past.

Obviously, we’re both tired and embarrassed. Each of us would like to reclaim some privacy. We hope the media and the public can respect that decision. Thank you for your understanding.”