Arizona State Education Budget Storm Looms for 2009

Gayle Plato-Besley, M. Ed.

With alarming news coming from the state legislature about potentially drastic budget cuts, local media and state educators are scrambling to either explain or blame current politicians, outgoing Governor Napolitano, or the economic downturn in general.  Little discussion exists as to what to do about the reality. 

Scottsdale Unified School District‘s Sherry Celaya, Director of Finance, handles daily workings of district-wide budgeting.  She summed up the reality facing many school districts in her response to Sonoran Alliance about pending budget woes: 

 “If SUSD loses full day kindergarten funding we will lose 51 teaching positions.  This will take effect immediately at the start of the 2009-10 school year. The only way we could continue to accommodate full day kindergarten is through our K-3 Override.  Moving full day kindergarten to the K-3 Override will negatively impact the current class size ratios in grades K-3.”
 

 

Arizona‘s budget/financial crisis is no surprise with national economic depression looming.  Yet, dire projected business failures, rising unemployment, and overall tax base decline for future state revenue makes this financial implosion a fiscal F5 tornado.

Ms. Celaya of SUSD, voiced a concern all educators face; districts statewide are going to face cuts, shufflings of staff, and potential class size increases.  Staff cuts seem inevitable.  As many teachers in Arizona are members of the Arizona Education Association, they may look to the AEA for guidance in this difficult time. AEA has members on the coalition noted in this article. 

The home page of the AEA has an enlightening comment from their president, John Wright:


 “
Arizona’s leaders are willing to shoulder the burden of their own financial mismanagement over the years on the backs of our students.  This kind of false solution is worse than shortsightedness; it borders on malice.  The decision to keep Arizona at the bottom of education funding continues to be a deliberate one.”

Can the AEA face the reality that every other leader of industry faces today?  Or, are teacher unions truly hurting it’s members by the teeth gnashing, partisan pack-like behavior?   The storm is coming and the best thing to be done is to jump in and help steer the ship out of the worst chop.

Blame may be the choice for the moment, but united action and review of policy will be necessary.  The Arizona Business and Education Coalition (ABEC), started in 2002, is designed to review exactly how organized discussion and partnership could offer effective change to meet the needs of schools.  For years, this group has advocated for better funding and promoted a joint effort:
 
“Policy makers, educators, citizens, and business leaders must hold each other jointly accountable for improvements in the financial and academic condition of our schools by working proactively to create long-term funding that supports long-term investment in
Arizona and its future. ” (ABEC, http://www.azbec.org/schoolfinance.cfm)

This reality of the budget is painful for any educator. Administrators will eat this and many a superintendent will be thrown overboard once cuts come down. The formula for raising money in the state may be outmoded too as the Average Daily Membership (ADM) funding marked by the 100th day attendance report for each district is the foundation for funding.

“The 27-year-old school funding formula couldn’t have foreseen the challenges we face today.  It’s time to take another look.  Wouldn’t it be great to have a solid funding structure in place that would meet the needs of 21st Century learning?” -Susan Carlson of ABEC Blog (http://www.azcentral.com/members/Blog/scarlson/16463)

Yet, the message beat home by all who advocated for the current plan is that more is better, and students benefit as state funding increases. But that’s not necessarily true.  According to the State of Arizona office of the Auditor General, there has been a steady decrease in classroom dollars by school districts statewide.  Even though there has been a significant infusion of state-provided funds for classrooms, over half of the districts provided less classroom dollars per student in 2007 than they did in 2006. The report from February 2008 stated the following:

 ” Within Arizona, higher per-pupil spending does not equate to higher classroom dollar percentages. Although these (larger) districts have more resources available to spend per pupil, on average, they put a smaller proportion of each dollar in the classroom. As a result, districts with the highest per-pupil spending, on average, have lower classroom dollar percentages.”

(http://www.auditorgen.state.az.us/Reports/School_Districts/School_Districts.htm)

Proposition 301 is an example of voter mandate to fund classrooms, and increase teacher salaries.  Yet, according to the report, the majority of it has been used on salary increases and somewhat nebulous practices. The report also noted irregularities and misappropriation over the last few years.   The accountability and overseeing of districts’ usage of the funds is in question according to the Auditor General. 

Could Proposition 301 monies, or an Arizona Lottery revamp be utilized? A lottery is always a voluntary tax and generates funds even in recession.   Does the legislature have the right to freeze all 301 funds and re-direct the money to help the state weather the storm?  Could all school lunch and breakfast prices double for regular education students not considered free or reduced?   Could all school districts close down operations from late June to late July to shrink operation costs; follow up with a  cut all in administrative salaries by one month of pay? Could all school counseling and health/nursing services be contracted out with private agencies?

The ABEC offered a paper on school finance reform and quoted a well-known state expert regarding school budgets.  Alan Maguire helped create the current laws and financial model.  His recommendation follows:

ABEC School Finance Reform
http://www.azbec.org/SFR_Progress_Report_June_08.pdf

1) Understand “what is”: conduct an accurate,
thorough examination of current actual spending
levels and practices
2) Consider “what ought to be”: determine what the
“right” level should be to support achievement
3) Develop a tax proposal
4) Develop the mathematical allocation process

 Coalitions, think tanks, and parents with good ideas could help, flooding the state legislators in a massive brainstorm.  Maybe there is a need for districts to work the problem and freeze all committee discussion of any future programming.  Everything discussed in each meeting is about the budget only; nothing else matters if kids truly do come first.

 

Gayle Plato-Besley is a certified social studies teacher, and counselor with over 20 years experience working with children and families. Her experience includes work as a school counselor in Arizona and Washington school districts, private practice, and a secondary level teacher of U.S. Government, Economics, and History. She works as a freelance writer on topics of education, politics, and social commentary. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gayle_Plato-Besley)

 

Kyl Endorses James for GOP Chair

For Immediate Release: January 17, 2009

Lisa James earns endorsement of Jon Kyl for AZ GOP Chairman

PHOENIX (January 18, 2009) – Lisa James, elected state committeewoman from Legislative District 8, announced the endorsement of Jon Kyl (US Senator, R-AZ) in her run for Arizona Republican Party Chairman.

The following statement was issued: “I support Lisa James for Chairman of the Arizona Republican Party because she will provide the leadership to increase Republican voter registration, raise funds, recruit candidates and execute a successful get out the vote effort.”

“I am honored to have the support of Senator Jon Kyl,” said Lisa James. “Senator Kyl is well respected and appreciated by Arizona Republicans for his hard work and dedicated service advancing Republican principles. I look forward to working with him to unite our Party.”

To learn more about Lisa James, her goals for the Arizona Republican Party and view what others are saying, please visit the campaign Web site at www.lisaforchairman.com.

Update: MC Elections Results – Owens by 1 Vote!

Last Saturday, we reported on the election results of the annual organizational meeting of the Maricopa County Republican Party. In the election for Secretary, Sandy Doty and Kim Owens both tied for that position with 795 votes. Today an official hand count was conducted and the result was that Kim Owens has won by one vote.

Congratulations to Kim and we look forward to her volunteer service with the County Party!

Pullen Announces 16 State House Endorsements

For Immediate Release: January 16, 2009
Contact: Randy Pullen

Pullen Announces 16 State House Endorsements

Phoenix, AZ-Arizona Republican Party Chairman Randy Pullen today announced the endorsement for re-election as Chairman from 16 members of the Arizona House of Representatives. Included in the endorsements announced today were State Representatives:

  • Hon. Frank Antenori (LD-30)
  • Hon. Cecil Ash (LD-18)
  • Hon. Andy Biggs (LD-22)
  • Hon. Tom Boone (LD-4)
  • Hon. Judy Burges (LD-4)
  • Hon. Steve Court (LD-18)
  • Hon. Sam Crump (LD-6)
  • Hon. Doris Goodale (LD-3)
  • Hon. David Gowan (LD-30)
  • Hon. Nancy McLain (LD-3)
  • Hon. Steve Montenegro (LD-12)
  • Hon. Frank Pratt (LD-23)
  • Hon. Doug Quelland (LD-10)
  • Hon. Carl Seel (LD-6)
  • Hon. David Stevens (LD-25)
  • Hon. Jerry Weiers (LD-12)

“Randy Pullen lived up to his promises and made it the priority of the Arizona Republican Party to elect strong Republicans to state offices,” said Rep. Frank Pratt (LD-23). “As legislators, it is important to have our state party dedicated to working for Arizona Republicans.”

“Republicans in Arizona bucked the national trend and gained seats in both houses of the state legislature thanks to the hard work and dedication of Randy Pullen and his team,” said Rep. Judy Burges (LD-4). “I’m excited to help Randy continue building the Republican Party and winning races over the next two years.”

“Randy Pullen brings integrity, principles and commitment to our candidates to the office of chairman and I enthusiastically endorse him for a second term,” said Rep. Steve Montenegro (LD-12). “We have larger majorities in both the State House and State Senate, thanks in large part to the brains and the brawn that Randy Pullen and his team brought to our campaigns.”

Pullen said he was humbled by the support he was receiving from state legislators and from Republicans across Arizona.

“I look at the next two years as an opportunity to build on the successes we achieved in 2008,” said Pullen. “There are those who seem to spend all their time looking for things our party or our candidates might have done wrong, but I believe there are far more things we did right. As Chairman, I want to make people proud to be Republicans again. I want to make Arizonans proud and excited to join the Arizona Republican Party.”

Since first taking office in 2007, Chairman Pullen and the Arizona Republican Party have:

  • Successfully expanded Republican majorities in both the State House and State Senate;
  • Successfully elected new Republicans to county and local offices across the state;
  • Successfully increased the number of elected Precinct Committeemen by more than 300 Republicans statewide to record levels;
  • Successfully added more than 5,000 net new donors to the Arizona Republican Party’s donor file, an increase of more than 26-percent;
  • Successfully helped pass a stronger and more conservative national Republican Party Platform;
  • Successfully made it the official policy of the Republican National Committee to instruct Congress that first and foremost, America’s borders must be secured; and,
  • Successfully made it the policy of the Republican National Committee to encourage state governments to stop investing in companies based in nations that sponsor terror.

“I’m proud of our accomplishments these past two years, but I’m even more excited about the opportunities of the next two,” Pullen said. “It’s a great time to be an Arizona Republican.”

Brewer Names Directors of Communications, Legislative Affairs

For Immediate Release: January 16, 2009
Contact: Paul Senseman

Incoming Governor Jan Brewer Announces Communications, Legislative Directors

PHOENIX – Secretary of State Jan Brewer today announced two more additions to her senior staff in preparation for her new role as Governor of the State of Arizona. Paul Senseman will join her administration as Director of Communications and Scott A. Smith as Director of Legislative Affairs.

“Mr. Senseman and Mr. Smith bring a wealth of experience, knowledge and energy to the Governor’s Office. They both possess keen insight and familiarity of state government which will be invaluable during these challenging times,” stated Brewer. “They are consummate professionals in their fields and are welcome additions to my senior staff team.”

Paul Senseman will serve as chief spokesperson for incoming Governor Brewer and will guide all strategic communications operations for the Governor’s Office.

For the past five years, Mr. Senseman has been a public affairs consultant with the Phoenix public affairs firm, Policy Development Group. He has a broad background in public policy and communications at the State Capitol. He has served on the senior leadership staff of three Arizona House Speakers, most recently to the late‐House Speaker Jake Flake. He has been a strategist and advisor to numerous legislators, including positions as Director of Communications and Chief of Staff to the House Republican Majority. Prior to working at the State House, Mr. Senseman served on the Arizona staff of United States Senator John McCain.

Mr. Senseman received his Bachelor of Science in Political Science from Arizona State University West and is a former member of the Board of Directors of the ASU Alumni Association. He currently serves as a board member for the Dean’s Advisory Board of ASU’s New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences. Paul has served as Honorary Commander of the 309th Fighter Squadron at Luke Air Force Base and currently serves as Vice Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Phoenix Gospel Rescue Mission. He is a 4th generation Arizonan and native of Peoria, Arizona, where he resides with his wife Kathy, and their two daughters.

As Director of Legislative Affairs, Scott A. Smith will manage all legislative relations for incoming Governor Brewer.

Most recently, Mr. Smith has served as the Deputy Director of Operations for the Arizona Department of Administration with responsibility for numerous ADOA divisions including: the Arizona Capitol Police Department, the General Service Division, the Information Services Division, the Management Services Division, and the Telecommunications Program Office. He is a dedicated and conscientious public servant, with nearly 20‐years of state government experience in both management and legislative capacities.

Mr. Smith also served as the Director of State Relations for Arizona State University. He has served as the legislative liaison for the Arizona Department of Corrections and twice as the legislative liaison for the Arizona Department of Administration. Mr. Smith was also the Privatization Bureau Administrator for the Arizona Department of Corrections. He began his career in state service with the Arizona House of Representatives.

Mr. Smith earned his Bachelor of Science degree in Political Science from Arizona State University. He and his wife, Andrea, have been married for nine years and live in Scottsdale with their two daughters. Mr. Smith coaches his daughter’s softball team and serves on the board of his homeowners’ association. He is also a Sun Devil Club member and lifetime member of the ASU Alumni Association.

ADM Drives Education Budget in AZ

- Gayle Plato-Besley

Do you have an elementary-aged child getting ready to celebrate the 100th day of school soon?  It’s coming you know, and never in the history of Arizona has it been more important.  For those that attended school in Arizona over twenty years ago, you might not remember the hoopla about DAY 100. Years ago, it was just another day: no parade or party full of spectacle.

Yet DAY 100  is all in the news  for it is the ADM drop off point: Average Daily Membership (ADM), or the driving data used to determine your child’s fate in regards to funds, makes everybody stand up and take notice.  Average Daily Membership determines money per student sent out to the schools. 

ADM is calculated based on the 100 day attendence record, averaging out the number of kids per class, grade, school and district.  This is the KEY to determining how much money goes out, and how much per student may get cut.  It is why we celebrate perfect attendance in schools; it is why I was up too late with my Kindergartener pasting 100 things and coloring by tens.  It was a good lesson for him, but then it’s a vital lesson for us all.

Arizona State Legislators are gearing up for a fun game of pass the buck.  Each passes off budgetary woes, and blames the incoming Republicans for what’s gonna hit the fan.  As the Arizona Republic deftly put out there today, (http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/2009/01/16/20090116capitol-budget0116.html), the Republicans are out to get you parents, and cut all of the programs you like.  It’s their fault.  Sounds like high school girls whining when Dad takes away the cell phone after a huge bill comes in. Look for more woe in your district,  and definition of the budget as schools start to tabulate their piece of the shrinking pie. 

2009 Calendar of Events

Sonoran Alliance now has a calendar page for conservative events. If you would like your organization’s event posted, please email Sonoran Alliance with details, flyers, etc.

2010 Races Begin To Take Shape

It may be hard to believe, but candidates are already trying to get a jump on their competition.

In LD7, State Representative Nancy Barto has filed for the seat that State Senator Jim Waring will be vacating due to term limits.  In so doing, Barto appears to be trying to block out State Representative Ray Barnes, who is facing term limits himself.

In LD9, State Rep Rick Murphy has filed an exploratory committee for Senate President Bob Burns’ seat.

In LD14, State Rep Robert Meza is exploring a run for the Senate.

In LD15, Democrats are lining up, double time, as both Katie Hobbs and Luis Garcia have already filed to run for the House seat, while Kyrsten Sinema is exploring a run for the Senate seat that Ken Chevront will be vacating due to term limits.

In LD16, Democrat Jimmie Munoz is going to give it another try for the State House seat.

In LD20, Republican Christopher Tolino has filed to run for the State House seat that Democrat Rae Waters captured in November.  At present, Tolino is an unknown, although we’ll be trying to learn more.

In LD27, Democrat Bob Gilby has filed for the House.

Face it…We Need A New Strategy

The Arizona Republican Party is in need of a makeover…

Some might even say an extreme makeover.  I would like to think that with a new focus on building our Party and working against the Democrats rather than fighting amongst ourselves, we can be not only prepared in numbers for 2010 and beyond, but we can be significant on many fronts.

Lisa James is a proven leader.

Lisa is well-respected across the state for her hard work on the Bush campaigns and within the Party for her experience, skills and knowledge to ramp up registration, increase the donor base, and bring home the vote without compromising the Party Platform.  Lisa has a track record of leadership on the national, state and local levels as well as where it counts most…at home.

Lisa is innovative and involved.

Lisa has worked hard to recruit new faces to the Party and bring the thrill and excitement of being involved in Republican values  to life.  Through the Dodie Londen Excellence in Public Service Series, women of all ages are educated and trained to take on leadership roles in Arizona. Lisa helped developed the concept and sits on the Dodie Londen Board in order to “increase the number and influence of Arizona’s Republican women in government and politics.”  Lisa has also worked hard helping strong conservative Republicans run in national, state and local elections, both as a volunteer and professional consultant.

Lisa has the know-how and savvy to win in 2010 and beyond.

Personality and grass roots support are very important. However, the bottom line is registration and money. We may have won seats in the state legislature in 2008. But, the reality is we lost in fundraising and we continue to lose in the registration battle. The re-districting lines are what saved our majority this year in the legislature, not registration or funding.  Lisa will be able to use her professional campaign and political experience to prepare us for victory. Her willingness to give her strengths and talents to the Party as a volunteer Chairman should not go unnoticed. Although she has volunteered for plenty of grassroots activities and campaigns, having someone of her professional caliber is certainly a huge bonus.

Lisa has the facts.

If we do not start immediately giving citizens a reason to come back to the Party, we will be in the minority in four more years. 80% of those who registered in the past two years registered Democrat or Independent. That has to change. Lisa has the foresight to appeal to new voters and displaced voters without ignoring our principles.  We have much work to do between now and the 2010 election. There is no reason Bob Stump, Kris Mayes and Gary Pierce should have to work with Sandra “I am liberal and proud of it” Kennedy and Paul “County Car Toting” Newman.  Lack of funding killed our team. Just ask Marion McClure and Barry Wong what went wrong.

We need Lisa.

Kim Owens has a nice way of describing why, at this particular time, the Party needs Lisa, “Lisa James has the knowledge and skill to keep our party relevant and successful while staying true to conservative principles. She understands the changing landscape of Arizona and American politics and can navigate them well without sacrifice to the Republican platform.”

Most of us understand the Republican Party is in trouble. Let’s put a new face on and do something about it before it is too late. 

Pullen Campaign Website Up & Running

Arizona Republican Party State Chairman Randy Pullen’s website has gone from “Under Construction” to “Up & Running”.  It can be viewed here.  While Pullen’s opponent, Lisa James, is listing each of her personal endorsements, Pullen is sticking with lists of State Senators and Party Officers who are supporting him.  We’re told that his State Representative list will be out soon.  Hopefully, Pullen’s folks will list state committeemen endorsements so that we can start to take measure of the status of the race.  In the meantime, we’ll give the Best Website nod to Pullen in this race.  It is a sharp looking site.

Mesa Councilmen Kavanaugh On Domestic Partner Registry

Hat Tip to Mesa Issues for going “straight to the horses mouth” on the Mesa Domestic Partner’s Registry being proposed by Councilman Dennis Kavanaugh.

According to the response submitted to Mesa Issues Kavanaugh believes:

the registry is an equitable way to ensure visitation rights for unmarried couples. It also is helpful for the medical community by minimizing the risk of conflicts over who has access to patients in their facilities. (Read the entire letter.)

At this point, Kavanaugh has asked the Mesa Human Relations Advisory Board to study the proposal and make recommendations.

A visit to the City of Mesa’s Human Relations Advisory Board website provides the following information about the Board:

The Human Relations Advisory Board advises the City Council about racial, religious, ethnic, cultural, disability or other human relations issues affecting the City of Mesa and delivery of City services to Mesa residents, businesses, and visitors. The board recommends policies to eliminate discrimination and prejudice and to promote mutual understanding and harmony. The board serves as a public forum for citizen input on human relations issues. Meetings are held on the fourth Wednesday at 6:00 p.m. at the Council Chambers, 57 E. First Street, or at other locations throughout the City. Members are appointed for staggered terms of three years and represent the City’s diverse population. Call (480) 644-5033 for information.

It also provides a list of the current members of the Board as follows:

  • Terry Benelli, Chair
  • James May, Vice Chair
  • Ana Cadillo
  • Robert Carlston
  • Renee Coelho
  • Rory Gilbert
  • Lisa Hudson
  • John Matthews
  • Douglas McCarter
  • Mark Tompert
  • Everette Woods, Sr.

Based on the description of the Board, members of the public can provide input to the Board at the next meeting which will be held on Wednesday, January 28th at 6 PM.

Thomas: Won’t Prosecute Gilbert Mayor Steve Berman

Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas has just revealed that there will be no prosecution of Gilbert Mayor Steve Berman on domestic violence charges.

According to the County Attorney’s Office, witness statements are inconsistent regarding the charges against Berman. In addition, statute of limitation issues prevent prosecution.

Sonoran Alliance will provide the official press release once they are available. A press conference is scheduled today at 4 PM.

Update: Here is the text of the press release issued by Maricopa County Attorney’s Office:

No criminal charges will be filed against Gilbert Mayor Steve Berman due to legal and evidentiary deficiencies. A domestic violence investigation involving Mr. Berman and his current wife was routed to the County Attorney’s Office. The County Attorney’s Office then investigated further and learned of past allegations of domestic violence against Mr. Berman that happened between 1984 and 1994. While the investigation was underway the current Mrs. Berman recanted her statements and she and her husband have since reconciled. Our investigators also learned that past claims of domestic violence from step children and two ex-wives were previously reported to law enforcement. As a result, the statute of limitations prevents prosecutors from filing charges in connection with the alleged past incidents.

Napolitano’s final State of the State: Let me brag about what I spent to give us the worst budget deficit ever

Napolitano’s State of the State was full of the usual meaningless clichés and self-congratulations for adding and expanding more government programs. The speech wasn’t necessary, since the State of the State speech is supposed to be about where the state is headed and Napolitano no longer has any input into that, but Napolitano never saw a camera opportunity she didn’t like. She said she was sad since it would be the last time she would be addressing Arizonans like this, but unfortunately knowing how much she loves the limelight she’ll be back all too soon to run for Senate.

Hopefully she is not taking her speechwriter with her, there were so many meaningless clichés it began to sound painful. Here are some of the worst ones:

“move our state forward” (as if anyone might actually be in favor of moving our state backwards?)
“safer and stronger than ever before” (no, we’d rather be weaker and in jeopardy)
“All of us give ourselves for the greater good” (nah, we’ll just opt out of the U.S.)
“Arizona is young and dynamic, it is primed for success” (as opposed to a state like Ohio that is old and looking at defeat)
“I will do my utmost at the Department of Homeland Security as I have done my utmost here” (there was some concern that I would not do my utmost, so I’d better clarify)
“generations will remember how we educated our children” (is there any reason to think they wouldn’t remember?)
“Our state is called to show its commitment to children” (as opposed to being uncommitted to children by what, eliminating them?)
“We need to show the world Arizona is open for business.” (no, let’s show the world we’re closed for business)
And her closing cliché – “An Arizona that will continue to build its longterm future” (naw, let’s just dissolve the state)

Napolitano began her speech saying with a straight face (you expected to hear the audience laugh) that she has presented balanced budgets every year she was in office. Even the liberal Arizona Republic reporters have reported over and over again how this was a façade, Napolitano merely used gimmicks to hide the fact she was borrowing from future revenues and disguising debt. You don’t suddenly end up with a $2.6 BILLION deficit – the second worst state budget in the nation according to the Goldwater Institute – if you’re presenting balanced budgets every year. $2.6 billion doesn’t just pop up one year out of nowhere.

She claimed that she set money aside in the rainy day fund, but the Goldwater Institute also refuted this, in an article noting that Napolitano failed to save any money during the years the state was bringing in healthy revenues.

She then blamed the deficit on the recession! And launched right into the remainder of her speech, which was nothing but listing all the government programs she was responsible for expanding or creating while in office. Uhhh, this massive expansion of government under her was not responsible for the biggest deficits in Arizona’s history.

The centerpiece of her speech was education, which was the biggest issue she ran on for governor. The Goldwater Institute has done a thorough job of reporting how education is worse than it was when Napolitano entered office, so it was a bit nervy of Napolitano to make her record on education the centerpiece of her last State of the State speech. One of the biggest expansions of government in education Napolitano rammed through was all-day kindergarten in the public schools. The Goldwater Institute found that all-day kindergarten has a negligible affect on children by grade 5. In other words, it’s nothing more than taxpayer-funded daycare. Considering this is one of the biggest expenses that has been added to the state’s budget under Napolitano, contributing to our 2nd worst deficit in the nation, it is an embarrassing “accomplishment.”

Napolitano claimed that she cut Arizona’s high school dropout rate almost in half. But according to the Goldwater Institute in a 2005 report, Arizona has had the worst dropout rate in the nation since 1991, with 11% of students dropping out every year. Doubtful that a miracle suddenly happened between 2006 and 2008. If it did, she would have said what it was.

Napolitano repeated one of her tired old mantras, which is that more money must be spent in public school classrooms. Throwing more money at public schools doesn’t work. Arizona spends $8,500 per student, which is about the same as the U.S. average for all states. The schools that spend the most per pupil, $15,000, in Washington, D.C., are dead last in the nation for grades.

Next Napolitano bragged about how she tripled the amount of financial aid available to college students, and said that she has asked the universities to double the number of bachelor degrees they award by 2020. But was this really necessary? The workforce doesn’t need additional college graduates. In a fairly recent study from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, it was found that only 29% of jobs require a college degree. 40% of Americans currently obtain college degrees. If college degrees are optional for many, they shouldn’t be funded on the backs of other taxpayers.

Napolitano bragged about increasing construction projects at Arizona’s public universities, saying they’re creating more jobs. She neglected to say that they are also creating more debt for taxpayers. Arizona State University is the biggest public university in America. Why are we continuing to pay for government universities to increase in size when there are plenty of private colleges that offer quality education without breaking the backs of taxpayers?

The next spending project Napolitano congratulated herself on was increasing funding for research facilities at the public universities. Again, why is it necessary to fund research that is already being done well in the private sector at private universities?

Next, Napolitano gloated how she would be bringing home pork from the federal government soon, in the form of money for an “infrastructure stimulus plan,” whatever that is. Probably more money to expand light rail.

She said she is recommending that the legislature increase funding for “desperately needed school buildings.” That’s funny, the legislature is always complaining how half the budget is untouchable by them since a huge chunk of it was designated in a voter proposition to go to school facilities; Arizona’s schools have some of the best facilities funding in the nation. It goes without saying that some of the cash-poor charter schools that meet in trailers and mobile homes have the highest test scores in Arizona.

There was the inevitable discussion of her TIME initiative, which would have wiped out Arizona’s budget completely had it made it to the ballot and passed. A whole list of special interest groups was set to benefit from it. Rep. Andy Biggs described it the best: “It raises sales tax rates nearly 18% for 30 years to pay for a litany of wasteful projects. Her plan includes $1.7 billion in giveaways to environmental groups and billions more to light rail and inter-city trains.”

The Western Climate initiative was brought up, and Napolitano repeated the Democrat global warming scare talking points about how we need to limit greenhouse gases. Not only is the Western Climate initiative costing the state a lot of money to participate in, but it’s not within the state’s jurisdiction to address. It is wastefully duplicating the federal government’s efforts.

She bragged about how she had increased the number of people who were taking advantage of the Earned Income Tax Credit (remember her emails urging people to take advantage of it?). The Earned Income Tax Credit is not a credit, and it has nothing to do with earned income. It is a straight giveaway of other taxpayers’ money to people earning around $20k or less. If you’re a middle class student living on student aid and working a part-time job, you too qualify and get some of other peoples’ money for nothing.

Foreclosure spending was the next topic. Napolitano beamed discussing how not only did the federal government throw money at Arizona’s homeowners, but the state did as well. What she didn’t say is that although it is sad to see people have to sell their homes and move back into apartments, it would teach them financial responsibility. Otherwise they are likely to repeat the error of their ways, buying homes they can’t afford and continuing to buy non-necessary cell phones, big-screen TVs, brand-new cars, etc. We have the highest standard of living in the world. People living in Third World countries would give their right arm to live in a fully furnished apartment with electricity, running water, with money to spare to buy luxuries like cell phones and new cars. The greedy attitude that everyone must have a house is not realistic, since people will always buy beyond their means, buying non-necessary things they can’t afford on top of the house.

Napolitano said it would be wrong to hurt the poor in the name of balancing the budget. That is not reality. In reality, you hurt the poor when you enable them to spend beyond their means, and they never learn financial responsibility so they are constantly thrown into one financial hardship after another. And most of those who lost their homes due to foreclosure were not “poor,” but middle class, who had bought homes that were too expensive for them.

Then Napolitano took credit for cutting $1.8 billion in spending within the past 2 years (did not hear anyone laughing?). In reality, this was accomplished thanks to our Republican legislature that made necessary cuts to bloated, unnecessary, and unaffordable government.

She listed some more government programs that she wants to see taxpayers spend more money on; kidscare and prescription drugs. As we all learned in the last election, McCain lost to Obama because the voters were so disgusted with how bloated Bush had grown the government, particularly with the prescription drug discounts. Apparently Napolitano doesn’t listen. As for kidscare, it would expand government insurance coverage of children to families making up to 300% of the federal poverty level. Middle class – not just poor – families making $60k/yr would get free public healthcare for their children. Everyone else left in the nation making more money than that can’t afford to cover those costs.

The part of her speech bragging about Arizona’s efforts fighting illegal immigration was particularly funny. She took credit for the efforts that leaders like Sen. Russell Pearce, Sheriff Arpaio, and County Attorney Andrew Thomas have made in this area. It was insulting considering those principled men take a beating regularly in the mainstream media for standing up and representing common Arizonans, unlike Napolitano. Napolitano has vetoed every single illegal immigration bill that has ever crossed her desk except one, and that was only because she got trapped into it. She said she is offering a bill that would expand human trafficking laws to include human smugglers. This didn’t make any sense, because the state already has a law against human smuggling, and Arpaio and Thomas have arrested and prosecuted hundreds of illegal immigrants and smugglers under it. Clearly she was offering another meaningless gesture to make her look good only.

Ironically, furious that the legislature had gone around her vetoes and sent illegal immigration bills to the ballot, Napolitano then recommended that the law be changed to prohibit the legislature from doing this. She said the number of legislators required to send an initiative to the ballot should be increased to equal the number of legislators required to override one of her vetoes.

She ended her speech touting her most recent new government program, az211.gov. It is supposed to be a place where people can volunteer to help the state. There are a few choice government projects that she has listed on the site that she wants to steer people to volunteer for. Ahhh, we get it. She is trying to get people to work FOR FREE for the government, so government can get even bigger for free!

Arizona Right to Life PAC Speaks on Arizona GOP Chairmanship

The Arizona Right to Life Political Action Committee has released the following statement (from LightHouse Blog):

The Arizona Right to Life PAC has reviewed the candidate questionnaires for both Chairman Pullen, and his opponent, Lisa James. Both candidates’ responses were found to be in-line with the pro-life legislation and pro-life agenda of Arizona Right to Life PAC. Seeing no discernible difference among the two candidates, based on the questionnaires alone, the Arizona Right to Life PAC has decided that both candidates would carry the pro-life cause with them to the Chairmanship of the Arizona Republican Party.

This should make the Life issue a non-issue with those Republicans seeking differentiation between either candidate.

Brewer Issues Statement on Napolitano

The following statement was issued by Secretary of State Jan Brewer in regard to Janet Napolitano’s State of the State address:

Statement of Secretary of State Jan Brewer
January 12, 2009

“Today is Governor Janet Napolitano’s day. I thank the Governor for her service to our great state and wish her Godspeed in the enormous task that awaits her.

“I extend my heartfelt congratulations to all the members of the 49th Legislature. I, along with Secretary of State-designate Ken Bennett and my newly assembled executive staff, look forward to working hand-in-hand with the new Majority and Minority leadership teams in both chambers.

“Large tasks and tough decisions await us. By working together, we will guide all of Arizona to a new period of prosperity.”

Opening Session!

The Arizona Legislature in now convening and conducting its opening ceremony. My Pastor, Cal Jernigan, of Central Christian Church of the East Valley just delivered the invocation. The children of incoming Speaker of the House, Kirk Adams, delivered the Pledge of Allegiance.

You can watch the ceremony online by clicking here.

Coalition for a Conservative Majority meeting Monday night

CCM
Grassroots activist Rob Haney will discuss the important role of the precinct committeemen and women, and what they can accomplish.

Next meeting: January 12

Meeting Time: 7pm

Meeting Place: Arizona American Italian Club
7509 North 12th Street
Phoenix
CCM
Click here to join CCM or sign up for their emails.